Evidence is a document, not a confidence
A supplier who says a page “appears in AI answers” has told you almost nothing you can act on. Ask which question they are answering. Appearance, citation, indexing and traffic are four different observations, produced by different systems, and none of them is a ranking estimate.
Google states that eligibility for its AI features is an eligibility condition only, and explicitly does not guarantee crawling, indexing or serving. Microsoft describes its AI visibility reporting features in Bing Webmaster Tools — Intents, Topics, Citation Share and Compare, then in preview — as observational rather than a ranking system, and says labels may be broad for niche domains. Both are vendor statements about their own products; neither is an independent verification of your outcome.
The practical consequence for a brief: every reported observation should name the tool that produced it and the date. If the report cannot do that, it is an anecdote with a logo on it.
Sources Google Search Central, AI features and your website; Optimizing your website for generative AI features. Microsoft Bing blog, AI visibility reporting (preview). Pages last updated as shown on each source; vendor guidance, not independent testing.